*****************************************************************************
UPDATE: 082911 1241 PDT: Professor Mass of U-WA's Atmospheric Sciences department, now says that there NEVER were ANY reports which indicated that Irene was even a Cat-1 hurricane as and after it made landfall. It appears certain now that New Yawk City and other places were suckered into shutting down whole cities, at a cost of billions of dollars, for a weakening Tropical Storm. The flash-flooding that followed was NOT properly highlighted by NOAA, so, the chief climate-science arm of the US Government got it wrong both ways, over-doing the wind aspect and under-doing the flooding potential.
****************************************************************************
Yabu, a regular commenter, beat me to print on what I wanted to say here about the over-hyping of Irene, so just go back one post and read his comment. It's totally to the point.
Why WAS this hurricane over-hyped?
OK, this IS a righty blog, so let's get to the core of it, shall we?
This is all about "never let a crisis go to waste" Yabu touched on this, but I'd bet if we could search emails and inter-departmental memos of NOAA for the past week or so, we'd find some where they were INSTRUCTED by the Administration to keep their warnings on the heavy side.
Then there's Obama himself. Didn't he say that ALL hurricane damage would be made good by the Feds? That's just wrong, wrong, wrong. There's a process for this, one which has existed for decades. The localities which suffered damage petition their State governments for monetary relief. In turn, those State executives may petition the Federal Government for a Declaration of Disaster, which then opens the door for the Small business Administration to make very-low-interest loans to INDIVIDUALS who have compensible damages (this system pre-dates FEMA, which has hijacked it to a large degree). The municipalities and the States have a method of getting Federal cash also. So, the system already exists to use taxpayer funds to help relieve storm damages.
The problem with the existing systems, though, is that Obama can't claim much credit for using them, since others have gone before him to fix the Nation after disasters. So, he makes a "Disaster Declaration in Advance", something which is NOT in the Federal policy for Disaster Declarations. Follow the logic: he directs NOAA to over-hype the storm, and they do. He then says, "it's gonna be a bad one, but don't worry, Obama and crew will pull you through." So he shoots the dice, but comes up craps, because despite NOAA's Dire Warnings, the storm is a wet gale, not much more, and that WAS foreseen, since the storm was losing central pressure (a direct indication of it's strength) from just after it's Bahamas strike until it made landfall on Cape Hatteras.
Now, it is up to the Right to show up Obama's tinkering with the proven Disaster Declaration system here. Bit by bit, we will put it together, and after we do, I hope that the House of Representatives holds hearings on this obvious Cloward-Piven attempt by the President to boost his sorry performance ratings.
When disaster prep, warnings, and recoveries are done wrong, people die, people are misled and people lose property. It is important that all this disaster prep is done accurately, and the means exists to do it more accurately, yet it wasn't done accurately.
Yabu is right. Some heads need to roll for this. If NOAA can't do the job with all those tools at their command, there are plenty of private, commercial concerns who could. Names like The Weather Channel and Accuweather come to mind. If those firms had NOAA's tools at their command, this storm would not have been used as a political meat-axe as it was, it would have dampened a few events up and down the Eastern Seaboard, caused some minor moderate high-water damages as it did, and then taken it's place among the minor storms.
Does anyone want to bet that when the Feddle Gummint gets the bills for storm prep and damages, a significant piece of that bill will be for direct response to the Federal over-hype? When those bills come up for appropriation, the House ought to send them directly to the Democratic Party for payment.
"Six to eleven feet of storm surge in New York harbor" was NOAA's prediction. The actual surge? 3.8 feet.